| ▪ 14:00-15:00: Welcome in the room and one-on-one meetings |
|
▪ 15:00: Opening of the Conference, introductory notes and protocol, introduction of the session
Mr. Thomas EGLI, Host of the Geneva Forum (Geneva Forum) and Chair, Switzerland |
|
| ▪ 15:10-15:50: Pitch round (6 min. max. per speaker) |
|
● Thomas EGLI, Objectif Sciences International Monitoring Real Research in Citizen and Participatory Science: Towards a Common Tool for Design, Support and Evaluation
How can we determine whether a project presented as participatory is actually carrying out genuine research? The question concerns both the scientific and technical reality of the research : research questions, state of knowledge, methods, production and quality of data or other forms of evidence, analysis and learning and its human, educational and behavioural reality: are participants genuinely placed in a research situation, or are they mainly observing, carrying out predefined tasks, or taking part in science communication activities? The same question arises whether the project originates from a bottom-up citizen initiative, is proposed top-down by researchers in a participatory format, or emerges peer-to-peer from a shared encounter. For several years, Objectif Sciences International has been using a tool for monitoring real research designed to support its Research Programme Managers and the projects they oversee. A recent review of this tool, benchmarked against frameworks for defining and evaluating research, citizen and participatory science reference frameworks, and various international assessment models, has confirmed several of its core principles while also revealing significant opportunities for improvement. These include distinguishing more clearly between intentions and observable facts, replacing certain indirect indicators with phenomena that more directly reveal actual scientific activity, monitoring the trajectory of a project before, during and after implementation, and making the tool practical enough for everyday use without turning monitoring into a burdensome administrative process. The new version under development is based on a common transdisciplinary core, highly informative sentinel questions, the triangulation of several observations and, where necessary, discipline-specific investigation. The same tool should be usable to select a project, define its scope, support its development, monitor its actual activity, identify difficulties, document learning, decide whether it should be redirected or discontinued, and capture methods that can be transferred to other projects. The Geneva Forum in December 2026 will provide an opportunity to discuss and challenge this architecture. Work carried out in January and February 2027 will then lead to a first operational version. The ambition extends beyond OSI’s own use: the aim is to develop a tool that could be adopted by any platform commissioning or hosting citizen and participatory science operators, useful to operators themselves for managing their projects, but also to observers, funders and public authorities seeking clear, documented evidence of the scientific reality of the projects they support or finance.
|
|
| PART 1 - Co-Creating Knowledge: Inclusive Methods and Participatory Research |
|
● Korinna KAPPLER Photovoice community research on nature perception and values in an urban riparian forest in Southern Germany
Urban riparian forests provide important habitats for biodiversity while serving as recreational spaces for local communities. However, little is known about how dynamic changes in forest structure influence public perceptions, expectations and values. Along our study area at the Middle Isar River in Southern Germany, large forest areas were designated as protected natural forests in 2020 and have not been actively managed since. As a result, different stages of forest development can be observed, ranging from formerly intensively managed stands to more natural woodlands. We investigate how these changes influence public perceptions, expectations, and values, and how societal perspectives can contribute to future forest management. To explore how people perceive and value these dynamic environments, we apply Photovoice, a qualitative participatory research method that encourages participants to actively observe their surroundings through photography and personal reflection. Participants take photographs in response to specific questions and provide short explanations on their chosen motifs. Additional questionnaires address their nature values, attitudes towards the rights of nature, and related topics. The approach aims to engage participants directly with their natural environment and encourages reflection on their associations, preferences, and values. Beyond individual participation, we enable public volunteers to contribute to the analysis and discussion of the collected photographs and accompanying narratives. We also use selected contributions to develop local exhibitions in collaboration with volunteers. These exhibitions will take place in publicly accessible venues, such as cafés and libraries, making the findings available to a broader audience and encouraging dialogue about natural forest development. The findings are intended to contribute to a management concept developed by local forest authorities, providing insights into societal expectations towards urban natural areas, particularly those transitioning from managed to more natural ecosystems. By combining individual experiences with collaborative interpretation and public communication, the project also explores how participatory research can generate knowledge relevant to both society and forest management. A central question is how these perspectives can move beyond the research process and inform practical decision-making. The project therefore provides an opportunity to examine the potential of Photovoice to connect public engagement, scientific knowledge, and forest management, while identifying the challenges involved in translating participation into meaningful societal impact.
|
|
● Hafsa Siddique Drawing as Conversation: Co-creating a Visual Dictionary of Everyday Material Intelligence in Refugee Settlements
Long-term refugee settlements are continually transformed by the people who inhabit them. Through everyday acts of building, repairing, modifying and repurposing available materials, refugees and host populations negotiate the constraints of formal humanitarian infrastructure and adapt their environments to changing needs. Yet these small-scale material interventions are often overlooked or perceived as informalities to be corrected, or as clutter to be cleared, rather than as expressions of living ordinaries, situated knowledge and technical intelligence. My research proposes to investigate these everyday material adaptations through a participatory research-by-design methodology that treats drawing as a form of conversation. Working collaboratively with refugee and host populations, the research aims to explore how inhabitants’ knowledge, skills and reasoning can be documented through co-drawing, using both conventional and non-conventional forms of representation, and how these insights can be translated into a Visual Dictionary of Material Assemblages. The proposed dictionary will bring together drawings produced with inhabitants, and technical representations subsequently returned to communities for review and validation, recognising participants as co-authors of the knowledge generated. The research seeks to make visible the informal technical intelligence embedded in inhabitants’ material practices and to develop a transferable methodology for understanding how settlement environments evolve in response to social, cultural, environmental and material conditions. Beyond documentation, this visual knowledge could provide a basis for more context-sensitive humanitarian research, planning and programming. However, translating situated knowledge into formats legible to humanitarian organisations and planning institutions raises critical questions. How can informal technical intelligence inform formal decision-making without reducing the complexity of lived experience or appropriating the knowledge and agency of its creators? How can participatory documentation remain reciprocal, ensuring that the knowledge generated is meaningful and accessible to the communities involved? More importantly, how can the research create opportunities for tangible, immediate benefits for participating communities, rather than asking them to contribute knowledge whose potential influence may take years to materialise? As a proposed methodology that has yet to enter fieldwork, this contribution brings these questions to the Geneva Forum to examine the conditions connecting the production of participatory knowledge with its recognition, circulation and use. It invites discussion on how co-authorship, validation and knowledge exchange can be embedded in research design from the outset, and how the process of documenting everyday material practices might itself become an opportunity for reflection, exchange or practical benefit for inhabitants. Ultimately, the research asks how community-generated knowledge can create value for inhabitants in the short term while informing more responsive humanitarian practice and, in the longer term, changes to the policies and planning frameworks that shape refugee settlements. Often established through top-down emergency planning, refugee settlements frequently persist far beyond their anticipated duration, as the temporary becomes prolonged, and the needs and lives of their inhabitants continue to evolve. The research therefore seeks to explore how these pathways to impact might recognise and support inhabitants’ capacity to adapt their environments in response to everyday needs, rather than reproduce emergency-oriented planning approaches that, when extended over time, can constrain their ability to evolve in response to inhabitants’ own situated practices.
|
|
● Dr. Tiera Tanksley, UCLA Center for Resilience and Digital Justice GIEE Case Study: Glitching the System: Scaling and Expanding Youth-Led Critical AI Education
Context & Problem
As AI becomes increasingly prevalent in K–12 classrooms, two gaps remain unaddressed:
– Youth lack critical AI literacy curricula to interrogate and redesign AI more justly.
– Educators lack professional development to integrate and teach AI in ways that cultivate this critical youth agency. General Objective
GLITCH (Generating Liberation through Inquiry, Technology & Critical Hope) is a GIEE Case Study that prepares both students and teachers to become co-designers of more just technological futures. Specific Objective
GLITCH builds justice-oriented and community-centered AI programming for youth from under-resourced communities. It also generates, through youth co-design and participatory action research, professional development resources for educators seeking more just, joyous and culturally relevant approaches to AI in education. Alignment
By centering historically underserved youth and the K–12 educators who serve them, GLITCH advances:
– SDG 4: Quality education.
– SDG 10: Reduced inequalities.
– SDG 16: Building accountable, inclusive institutions. It also uses a Logical Framework approach (Geneva Forum, 2026) and is grounded in GIEE’s equity mission, the Global Learner Qualification Framework, and Global Online Education Regulator standards. Key Themes & Arguments
GLITCH’s model combines critical AI literacy, sociotechnical advocacy, and community inquiry with youth-led professional development for K–12 educators, validated through iterative curriculum design and longitudinal research. It centers three themes:
– 1. Youth agency in AI governance.
– 2. Teacher capacity for critical AI pedagogy.
– 3. Long-term systems change through workforce pathways and institutional partnerships.
This approach models how technology governance can be shaped by those most affected by algorithmic harm. Stakeholder Engagement & Methodology
This session speaks to education ministries, multilateral funders, and technology governance bodies seeking replicable models for equitable AI integration.
GLITCH’s participatory co-design methodology empowers historically underserved youth to develop scalable AI curricula alongside educators, researchers, community organizations, and higher education partners. Timing
– Years 1–2: Pilot and validation of curriculum and educator professional development.
– Years 3–5: Partnership expansion.
– Years 6–15: Full-scale ecosystem deployment, embedding GLITCH within national AI governance frameworks and public interest technology workforce pipelines. Expected Outcomes & Policy Impact
Since its founding in 2020, GLITCH has:
– Served 109 youth across five cohorts.
– Delivered approximately 10 professional development sessions, reaching an estimated 500–600 educators.
– Reached an average of 50–60 attendees per session, with a single session reaching 180 teachers. The next phase will produce:
– 1. A validated methodology.
– 2. Curricula piloted across three new partner sites.
– 3. 3–5 new GLITCH youth-focused courses.
– 4. A stackable educator credential completed by 1,000 educators.
– 5. A formal partnership with UCLA PIT Pathways, placing 25 youth alumni into postsecondary education or public interest technology (PIT) and data-science tracks.
|
|
● Myriam Da Silva, GIEE AI for SEN? What If We Got It Backwards?
Context & Problem
Despite growing investment in AI for education, students with Special Educational Needs (SEN) remain largely absent from the design, governance, and evaluation of technologies meant to serve them. Evidence on implementing responsible AI inclusively, sustainably, and with meaningful human oversight remains fragmented and unproven at scale. Core Objective & Alignment
Grounded in the Science of Learning, the Global Inclusive Education Ecosystem (GIEE), and AGILE’s Governance criterion, this case study co-designs a replicable responsible-AI implementation model with SEN learners, educators, and families, advancing SDG 4 (education), SDG 10 (inclusivity), SDG 16 (governance), and SDG 17 (partnerships) through direct learner participation in governance. Key Themes & Arguments
This international research explores how neuroscience-informed digital pathways enhance engagement for students with Special Educational Needs through a three-phase approach:
(1) Research and Co-Design of a SEN & AI Framework,
(2) Assessment and Piloting, and
(3) Implementation of a SEN Student Innovation Lab with community and industry partners to support global replication. Stakeholder Engagement & Methodology
Researchers seek policymakers, diplomats, and disability advocates to shape responsible AI for SEN education. Researchers will present the framework, gather insight on SEN and AI priorities affecting constituents, and offer a focus group to surface governance conflicts or opportunities. Expected Outcomes & Policy Impact
The SEN & AI Framework centers four components:
1) AI Literacy,
2) Learner Co-Design & Agency,
3) Human-in-the-Loop Governance,
4) Science of Learning and Learner Variability. Preliminary recommendations include mandatory SEN co-design in AI development cycles, procurement standards tied to accessibility testing, and governance protocols requiring human oversight of automated decisions.
|
|
● Dr. Krishauna Hines-Gaither, Mount Saint Mary’s University, Los Angeles A GIEE Case Study: Women in Artificial Intelligence Framework - A Global Paradigm of Gender Equity
Women in AI Case Study Members
– Krishauna Hines-Gaither, PhD : GIEE Women and AI case study team lead, Research and Development, Vice President for Strategic Initiatives and Partnerships, Mount Saint Mary’s University, Los Angeles
– Breann Branch, PhD, GIEE Women and AI case study team lead, Research and Development, Director of the Center for the Advancement of Women, Mount Saint Mary’s University, Los Angeles
– Giovanna Brasfield, EdD, GIEE Women and AI case study team lead, Women’s Leadership, CEO & Principal Consultant at Brasfield & Associates, LLC
– Myriam Da Silva, MA, GIEE Women and AI case study team member, Artificial Intelligence, CEO of CheckIT Learning, President of CheckIT In Foundation Glossary
– Advancement – Equitable roles in the home and workforce and access to leadership, education, STEM and economic mobility (UNESCO).
– Artificial Intelligence Literacy – Individual’s ability to comprehend, utilize and critically examine and evaluate artificial intelligence responsibly and ethically (UNESCO).
– Bias Mitigation – Engagement of developers, users and managers of artificial intelligence systems to reduce gender discrimination prevalent in data sets, algorithms and large language models (UNESCO).
– Well-Being – Dynamic state encompassing physical, mental, and emotional health, allowing individuals to thrive, learn, and feel safe (UNESCO).
– Women – Terminology includes all self-identified women 18 years and over. UNESCO defines gender within the paradigm of social construction acknowledging the roles ascribed to women and the discrimination that encompasses those roles. Women and AI Framework
In collaboration with Mount Saint Mary’s University, Los Angeles and the University of Barcelona, this initiative explores structural inclusion for women across the AI development lifecycle. Context and Problem
Globally, women comprise 22% of AI talent and are 25% less likely than men to use digital tools.
AI models do not incorporate women’s needs, and automation disproportionately impacts women. Many are under-skilled, slow adopters and lack trust in AI. Addressing this inequity aligns with goal 5 of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals to “achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls.” Core Objective & Alignment
With an investment in women’s digital futures, this study is grounded in the Global Inclusive Education Ecosystem. “Women leaders strengthen intergenerational and ethical alignment of capital (Agile, 2025, p. 47).”
This proposal presents a scalable, bankable framework that centers women and equips them to be leaders of artificial intelligence. Key Themes and Arguments
The case study seeks to determine whether a comprehensive framework that is uniquely designed for women can serve as an effective mechanism to support women users and developers.
Researchers will pilot with university students in Los Angeles and Barcelona, and with women workers. They propose a scalable 3-phase approach:
1. Research and Development of a Women and AI Framework.
2. Assessment and Piloting.
3. Implementation of a Women-Centered AI Innovation Laboratory. Stakeholder Engagement and Methodology
Researchers seek diplomats to offer guidance on their respective AI priorities and policy alignments.
Researchers will present the framework, gather insights on the AI needs of the diplomats’ women constituents, and offer a focus group to ascertain conflicts or opportunities. Expected Outcomes and Policy Impact
The Women and AI Framework centers four components:
1. Women’s AI Literacy
2. Women’s Advancement
3. Women’s Well-Being
4. Gender Bias Mitigation Preliminary recommendations include an increase in AI literacy, incorporation of women in the architecture of AI tools, regulations on AI and mental health, and bias mitigation protocols. The Logical Framework Tool
The Logical Framework Tool explicates a global state-of-the-art four-layer-framework.
Below, researchers describe how the Women and AI Framework addresses each layer.
– First layer – Vision of change: The Women and AI Framework shifts positionality from the disparity of women as AI users and developers to women becoming architects of change within AI systems.
– Second layer – Results chain: The final scalable and bankable result of the 3-phase approach will be the implementation of a Women-Centered AI Innovation Laboratory.
– Third layer – Measurement: The Women and AI Framework incorporates a 5-year capital milestone model that measures key performance indicators.
– Fourth layer – Adaptive management: The Risk Mitigation Plan acknowledges key assumptions, enumerates potential risks and offers mitigation strategies. References
Branch, B., Hines-Gaither, K., & Siebert, E. (2026).
The Future of Work for Women: Representation, Innovation and Access. Mount Saint Mary’s University, Los Angeles.
https://www.msmu.edu/media/website/learning-amp-research-communities/center-for-the-advancement-of-women/MSMU_RSWG_2026_FNL.pdf
Geneva Foundation for the Future (2025).
White Book AGILE: Impact Finance.
https://geneva-for-future.foundation/White-Book-AGILE.html
Geneva Forum (July, 2026).
The Logical Framework Tool for Framing an Impact Business or a Mission-Driven Project. Retrieved May 20, 2024.
https://www.geneva-forum.com/The-Logical-Framework-tool-for-framing-an-Impact-Business-or-a-Mission-Driven.html
Women4EthicalAI (n.d.).
UNESCO Artificial Intelligence and Emerging Technologies. Retrieved July 29, 2026.
https://www.unesco.org/en/artificial-intelligence/women4ethical-ai |
|
| PART 2 - Citizen Science for Environmental Knowledge and Territorial Resilience |
|
● Dr Madhulika Bhati, Dalhousie University, Halifax, Nova Scotia, Canada Co-Producing Scientific Understanding: Exploring Digital Twin application to mitigate Environmental Impact of Offshore Wind Farm
Nova Scotia currently plans extensive offshore wind infrastructure developments, raising urgent questions about how renewable energy development can proceed without compromising marine ecosystems. The Digital Twin for Offshore Wind and Marine Ecosystems (DT-OWF-MPA) emerges as a conceptual response to this challenge, envisioned as a dynamic, data-oriented virtual representation that encompasses both offshore wind farms and their surrounding marine environments. The research employed a systems-theoretical view on understanding the role of DTs in OWFs and Marine Protected Areas (MPAs) to capture the views and concerns of stakeholders on the potential development of a DT technology for managing OWFs in NS, with particular emphasis on monitoring, predicting, and optimizing trade-offs on environmental impacts, especially on MPAs. It also reports stakeholder perspectives on the value, feasibility, and governance requirements of DTs in the Nova Scotia context. Drawing on a multi-sector technical workshop, focus group discussion, and follow-up expert interviews, the study shows broad support for DTs as decision support tools for environmental monitoring and predictive "what if" scenario analysis. However, participants also identified significant barriers, including data fragmentation, high costs, institutional silos, limited technical expertise, and risks that complex models may become opaque "black boxes". The results highlight that technical capability alone is insufficient: social legitimacy depends on transparency, open data practices, and inclusive governance. The study suggests that small pilot projects offer a pragmatic pathway to test DT applications while building trust and capacity.
|
|
● Elizabeth MURRAY, A LIQUID FUTURE From Surfers to Coastal Intelligence: Connecting Participatory Science, Community Knowledge and Decision-Making
# From Surfers to Coastal Intelligence: Connecting Participatory Science, Community Knowledge and Decision-Making Coastal communities possess extensive knowledge of the environments on which they depend, yet their observations, experiences and priorities remain poorly represented in the scientific information and decision-making systems that shape their futures. At the same time, advances in low-cost sensing, digital technologies and data integration are creating new opportunities to connect community-generated knowledge with formal science and governance. Surfer Scientists, an initiative of A Liquid Future endorsed by the UN Ocean Decade, explores how surfing communities can contribute to this transformation. With an estimated 35 million surfers worldwide, surfing provides an established and expanding network of people who interact regularly with coastal environments, including in regions where sustained scientific observations and locally representative information are limited. The initiative uses the surf break as an entry point and organising geography for participatory coastal intelligence. Through accessible technologies, including low-cost sea-surface temperature sensors, tide gauges, drone imagery and community observations, Surfer Scientists seeks to combine environmental measurements with social, economic and governance knowledge. This approach recognises that understanding coastal change requires not only information about physical conditions, but also an understanding of how places are used, valued, managed and experienced by different members of society. Developed through collaborations with scientific institutions, ocean data infrastructures and community organisations, the initiative aims to establish pathways through which locally generated information can be integrated into wider observing and decision-support systems while remaining accessible and useful to participating communities. Partnerships involving NRF-SAEON, +ATLANTIC CoLAB, University College Cork, the Global Ocean Accounts Partnership and EMODnet provide opportunities to explore technical interoperability, the representation of social and environmental knowledge, and connections to policy and governance. An emerging demonstration pathway in Morotai, Indonesia, brings these elements together through a proposed community-led coastal intelligence pilot involving local communities, universities and government institutions. The proposed pilot will provide an opportunity to investigate two interconnected challenges: establishing pathways through which locally generated environmental and social knowledge can be recognised and used within scientific and decision-making systems; and ensuring that participating communities can access, interpret and use this knowledge to inform their own priorities and influence decisions affecting their coastal environments. Translating this approach into sustained practice will also require investment, institutional commitment and governance arrangements that support its development and potential replication across different coastal contexts. Through this approach, Surfer Scientists seeks to demonstrate how existing community networks, accessible technologies and scientific partnerships can connect local knowledge with wider observing and governance systems, strengthening communities’ capacity to participate in shaping the decisions that affect their coastal environments.
|
|
● Dr Marina Demchenko, PhD, LCARE Institute ; Living Cities Action Research Ecosystem The City Researches Itself: From Citizen Science to a Global Action-Research Ecosystem for Living Cities
The City Researches Itself: From Citizen Science to a Global Action-Research Ecosystem for Living Cities (Abstract) Cities generate unprecedented quantities of data, yet often lack the capacity to understand themselves as living social, cultural and ecological systems. Citizen science has significantly expanded public participation in knowledge production, but citizens are still frequently positioned primarily as contributors of observations or data. What becomes possible when citizens become co-researchers of their places - and when we can assess whether participation itself changes how people relate to their communities, territories and wider social systems? The Living Cities Action Research Ecosystem (LCARE) is developing a distributed international action-research architecture through which citizens, researchers, civic institutions, businesses and community actors collectively investigate their cities and territories. Its Soul of the City inquiry explores dimensions of urban life that conventional indicators frequently overlook: belonging, memory, identity, relationships with place, lived wellbeing, civic agency, cultural continuity, collective aspirations and perceived possibilities for change. Locally rooted Bioregional Action Research Clusters (BARCs) bring diverse stakeholders into iterative cycles of inquiry, collective sensemaking, experimentation and reflection. Locally generated knowledge can then be connected across an international learning ecosystem, enabling cities to learn from one another without reducing their distinctive cultural and ecological contexts to a universal model. LCARE integrates an additional measurement layer within this architecture. The INNER KEY© methodology provides a structured diagnostic approach to assessing internal and relational dimensions of human development, including wellbeing, resilience, developmental orientations and how individuals perceive themselves in relation to wider social systems. Integrated into longitudinal action-research cycles, it offers the possibility of examining changes before and after sustained citizen engagement: not only what participants learn about their city, but whether their sense of belonging, agency, responsibility and readiness to contribute to place-based development changes through participation. This creates a complementary approach to citizen-science impact assessment. Alongside observable environmental, social and policy outcomes, it becomes possible to investigate the less visible human conditions that may enable - or constrain - collective transformation. LCARE therefore proposes a shift from citizens as sensors towards citizens as co-researchers and co-creators, and from measuring only changes observed by citizens towards also examining changes within citizens and their relationships with place. The presentation will introduce LCARE’s emerging international action-research ecosystem, illustrate its application through current place-based inquiries, and invite collaboration on developing and validating an integrated framework connecting participatory knowledge production, measurable shifts in civic consciousness and agency, and regenerative action in cities.
|
|
| PART 3 - From Participation to Policy: Governance, Rights and Collective Action |
|
● Chloé Larose, Objectif Sciences International NGO How can international organizations better recognize participatory research and project-based learning as tools that not only educate young people, but also allow them to produce knowledge and contribute meaningfully to policy and sustainable development?
Participatory research and project-based learning are often approached primarily as educational methods designed to develop young people’s knowledge and skills. Yet their potential goes further. When young people participate directly in research projects, investigate real-world issues, collect and analyse data, and contribute to the development of solutions, they can become genuine contributors to knowledge production and sustainable development. This presentation will explore how international organizations can better recognize and support this dual role: education through participation, and participation as a means of producing knowledge and contributing to action. It will also examine how the results of youth-led and youth-inclusive projects can be better connected to institutional and policy processes, allowing young people to move from being beneficiaries of education to active contributors to research, decision-making and sustainable development.
|
|
● Prof. Dilek Sayedahmed, the Waterloo Institute for Social Innovation and Resilience (WISIR) Beyond the Room: When Participation Reaches Rulemaking
Participatory research can bring people into the room, generate knowledge, and make complex systems newly visible. Yet participation can occur after consequential decisions have already been made: the problem defined, resources allocated, options bounded, timelines fixed, and authority retained elsewhere. A simple question therefore precedes any claim of co-design: are we willing to let participation change what we do? A second follows it: what can participants actually change because they participated? This contribution examines the space between those questions through a multi-year participatory systems-mapping process within Canada’s social innovation and social finance ecosystem. More than 160 participants across six convenings collectively mapped resource flows, institutional bottlenecks, competing understandings of investment readiness, and uneven distributions of information and authority. The process generated substantial knowledge, collective sensemaking, and new ways of seeing the system. It also exposed a critical transition between seeing a system together and acquiring the institutional capacity to change it. Knowledge could travel while authority over funding parameters, evaluative criteria, accountability arrangements, and institutional rules remained more concentrated. Participation changed what could be collectively known before it changed what could be collectively decided. To investigate that transition, the Canadian experience is placed in comparative dialogue with four community-rooted governance arrangements. People’s Purse, participatory budgeting led by people with lived experience of homelessness, shows participants exercising authority over funding rules and allocation. The Five Rs of Rematriation, an Indigenous investment philosophy organized around relational, rooted, restorative, regenerative, and revolutionary principles, relocates authority over how investment and value are defined. Practical Systems for Indigenous Communities, a framework grounded in Sahtú Dene teachings, self-government, and longstanding governance practice, shows how understandable, useful, and teachable systems can support participation, adaptation, and community authority across connected levels. Banker Ladies and rotating savings and credit associations, Afro-diasporic feminist solidarity finance practices, show trust, reciprocity, shared risk, and mutual obligation operating as governance infrastructure. Comparison across these arrangements reveals different sites at which participation becomes institutionally consequential. Three conditions recur: shared rule-making, accountability organized as reciprocal learning, and self-organization across institutional scales. The cases illuminate pathways through which participation can reach resource allocation, evaluative authority, adaptive system design, and relational governance. The argument is: participation reaches transformation when what people know together can change what they are authorized to decide together. For participatory research concerned with lasting impact, getting people into the room is only the beginning. The harder question comes afterward: did participation reach the rules?
|
|
● Mrs. Mar Introini, The Sustainability Reader Towards a Zero Leadership era that empowers citizens beyond a transhumanist agenda
Towards a Zero Leadership era that empowers citizens beyond a transhumanist agenda We live under panoptic surveillance under the idea that it is better for security, without focusing on an ecosystem in high-values standards: education, critical thinking, and sensitivity. The relentless agenda from centralized power turns AI into a dangerous path for replacing humans in essential jobs, instead of being a tool controlled by humans. It challenges their capacity to evolve spiritually and emotionally as owners of human development. Recovering the place for civil society might be the challenge for the next decades: a democratic role for influencers in all stages of decision-making, including Diplomacy, Health, and education, instead of being led by the transhumanist agenda. A new leadership toward a swift shift that makes humans more moral and ethical, and makes humanoids and robots a tool for greater well-being.
|
|
● Dr. Vannucci Erica and MATERA Sonia, Deep Blue Srl From Participation to Institutional Impact: How the CLIPP Procedure Strengthens Municipal Emergency Preparedness Planning
Citizens are often the primary first responders during emergencies, possessing irreplaceable tacit knowledge of local geography, critical resources, and pre-existing community vulnerabilities. Yet, despite playing a vital role on the ground, citizens are rarely integrated into post-disaster evaluation and planning. As a result, valuable intangible heritage (e.g.,first-hand experiences, informal coping mechanisms, and grassroots solutions developed during crises) is lost rather than preserved for future events. While participatory science and research are increasingly recognized as essential for resilience, participation alone does not automatically produce lasting impact. A critical gap remains in translating community feedback into actionable inputs that update preparedness plans and drive formal institutional change. To address this critical transition from knowledge production to institutional impact, the Empower-Citizens project developed the CLIPP (Citizen & Authority Learning and Improving Preparedness Plans) Procedure. CLIPP provides public authorities and civil society organizations with an operational methodology to elicit, filter, and structurally integrate participatory input into official planning. It acts as the intentional mechanism ensuring impact is built into the very design of civic engagement. The procedure follows a five-stage framework:
– 1. Understanding the Local Context: Mapping actors to design inclusive, context-sensitive participation.
– 2. Fostering Dialogue with Citizens: Gathering lived experiences and crisis management insights.
– 3. Organising Information: Validating and combining local tacit knowledge with professional expertise.
– 4. Revising Preparedness Plans: Formally updating institutional disaster plans based on gathered data.
– 5. Sharing Lessons Learnt with Citizens: Communicating outcomes to sustain trust and ongoing collective action. This procedure has been tested in two concrete case studies, the municipality of Castelraimondo in Italy, and the county of Innlandet in central Norway. In the italian pilot of Castelraimondo, a full-cycle of the CLIPP procedure was applied, demonstrating how grassroot knowledge and participatory methods can directly transform territorial emergency preparedness. In Castelraimondo, residents, municipal authorities, and emergency responders collaborated to gather ground-level insights from citizens’ direct experiences of the 2016 Central Italy earthquake. The demonstrable result of this participatory process was the formal, evidence-based revision of the local municipal emergency preparedness plan. Executing the full CLIPP cycle requires dedicated facilitation, feedback collection, and inter-departmental coordination. For small and medium-sized municipalities operating under tight budgets and lean staffing, this administrative lift can push operational capacity to its limits or directly trigger the non-adoption of participatory approaches. Another vital critical element is ensuring political and administrative continuity of the CLIPP procedure adoption. Participatory processes frequently collapse when local governments change; sustaining the CLIPP process would require embedding the procedure into formal, legally binding administrative protocols so that institutional momentum is maintained across political turnover and electoral cycles. Empower-Citizens reimagined the citizens’ role in disaster preparedness, moving them from passive actors to active contributors, ensuring that those most impacted by crises have a structural seat at the decision-making table. The CLIPP procedure is a practical tool which operationalizes the "whole-of-society" approach, illustrating the precise conditions necessary for a participatory approach to become a genuine driver of change. It offers a transferable, scalable tool that institutionalizes citizens knowledge, proving that integrating the lived experiences of vulnerable populations can reliably produce demonstrable, and lasting impact on local disaster preparedness and resilience.
|
|
● Claire MIZUTANI, advisor to CLIMADA Commons Climate Risk Knowledge: A Right, Not a Privilege
Climate risk is a public good, yet knowing your risk is still a privilege. Detailed climate risk data is often costly, proprietary, difficult to access or interpret, or simply unavailable, especially at the local level where decisions are made. Today, the analysis that tells a city, a farmer or a small business what floods, heat or storms will cost them sits behind expensive models and consultancy fees. Those most exposed are often the last to know. CLIMADA Commons sets out to change this. It builds on CLIMADA, an open-source climate risk platform developed at ETH Zürich, to make climate risk data and insights open and usable by all. This talk shows how it is possible to journey from academia to an actionable public good. Access to this knowledge is part of the right to a clean, healthy and sustainable environment, recognized by the UN. Let’s make climate risk knowledge a right, not a privilege.
|
|
| ▪ 15:50-15:55: Statement of the question to be addressed |
|
| ▪ 15:55-16:35: Interactive round table (feedback session) Hosted by Thomas EGLI |
|
| ▪ 16:35-16:50: Break |
|
| ▪ 16:50-17:45: One-on-one meetings session |
|
| ▪ 17:45-18:00: Closing remarks |
|
| ▪ 18:00: End of the workshop |
|
| From 18:00: Networking opportunities (Networking) |
| At the end of this session a position paper will be published by the Geneva Forum to compile what was said and decided during the session. |
| ▪ 19:00: Geneva Forum Networking Dinner |